This was mentioned in another thread by merkin:
In a post on Fri Jun 11, 2010 at 7:19 pm, arnoldo wrote:I'm planning to read the book in chronological order but am not sure were to read Hadi Bennotto's in duniverse book, The Dune Encyclopedia. The beginning of God Emperor of Dune starts with Hadi Bennotto proclaiming the discovery of the Dar-es-Balat materials (which Teg possibly mentions in Heretics of Dune). Considering Hadi Bennotto was the editor of the Dune Encyclopedia should it be read before or after God Emperor of Dune?
With English corrected:
I'm planning to (re-?)read the books in chronological order but am not sure where to read Hadi Benotto's in-Duniverse book, The Dune Encyclopedia. The beginning of God Emperor of Dune starts with Hadi Benotto proclaiming the discovery of the Dar-es-Balat materials (which Teg possibly mentions in Heretics of Dune). Considering Hadi Benotto was the editor of the Dune Encyclopedia, should it be read before or after God Emperor of Dune?
Um... Seeing how the
The Dune Encyclopedia is supposedly based on materials found at Dar-es-Balat LONG AFTER Leto's death, if you're reading every piece of fan fiction related to Dune in "chronological order", the only sensible thing to do would be to read
The Encyclopedia AFTER
GEoD. There's really no question, is there? He really is a stupid little turd, isn't he?
FH in Heretics wrote: He found himself gripped by accounts from the archeological team that had found the Tyrant's primitive no-chamber on Rakis. Dar-es-Balat, the place was called. The reports by Archeologist Hadi Benotto were marked "Suppressed by orders of the Rakian Priesthood." The file number on the accounts from Bene Gesserit Archives was a long one and what Benotto revealed was fascinating.
...
"Let us not forget the Hadi Benotto translation of God's own holy words," another priest interrupted. "Shai-hulud referred many times to Siona."
The only remotely interesting question here (which arnoldo kinda dances around in typical arnoldo fashion but seems to miss completely) might be whether FH meant references to Benotto's work
only in his own books or if he might possibly have had
The Encyclopedia in mind as well.